Tuesday, September 24, 2013

Galatians 1:8-9 Brief

Belgium, I Eclaircie-trekearth

La Campagna, Italy-trekearth
Sole, Portoferraio, Italy-trekearth
















































I have been listening to an audio version of Galatians lately...

Galatians 1: 6-10 New American Standard Bible (NASB)

6 I am amazed that you are so quickly deserting Him who called you [a]by the grace of Christ, for a different gospel; 7 which is really not another; only there are some who are disturbing you and want to distort the gospel of Christ. 8 But even if we, or an angel from heaven, should preach to you a gospel [b]contrary to what we have preached to you, he is to be [c]accursed! 9 As we have said before, so I say again now, if any man is preaching to you a gospel [d]contrary to what you received, he is to be [e]accursed! 10 For am I now seeking the favor of men, or of God? Or am I striving to please men? If I were still trying to please men, I would not be a bond-servant of Christ.

Greek New Testament

Scrivener 1894 Textus Receptus
wV proeirhkamen kai arti palin legw ei tiV umaV euaggelizetai par o parelabete anaqema estw

Byzantine Majority
wV proeirhkamen kai arti palin legw ei tiV umaV euaggelizetai par o parelabete anaqema estw

Brief Background Of Galatians

Commentator F. Roy Coad makes the quite clear observation from the context, statement that Galatians is free from authorship controversies as it is virtually unanimous that the Apostle Paul wrote the Book. Coad (1986: 1413). Paul is clearly identified as the author.

There are debates on the date of the letter and the location of churches intended. Coad (1986: 1413). Many American and British scholars conclude Paul established on his first missionary journey a church in the southern part of the Roman Province of Galatia. (1986: 1416).

The writer reasons that Galatians was likely the first New Testament text written, in 48-49 AD, and Paul's conversion was likely in approximately 33 AD. Coad (1986: 1416).

Galatians 1: 6-10

Commentators with different views ask 'Was Paul implying that the Judaizers' message was no gospel at all; or that it was not a different message, but merely a perversion of the true?' Coad (1986: 1418).

The Judaizers being those formerly of Hebrew Religion of the Old Testament/Hebrew Bible in the early Christian Church that were attempting to live under Old Covenant Law and influencing others to do so.

However the Scriptural context states a different gospel (verse 6), contrary to what you received (verse 9).

Marshall states 'another gospel': eteron euaggelion

Coad states one that preaches such as gospel is 'eternally condemned' -anathema. Coad (1986: 1418).

ἀνάθεμα: Is translated as 'a curse' 'let him be' estw in Alfred Marshall's Greek Lexicon.

Bauer documents ἀνάθεμα: it is the 'object of a curse' in Galatians 1: 8 forward. Bauer (1979: 54).

Strong's documents ἀνάθεμα: A religious ban or excommunicated thing or person-accursed, anathema, curse x great. Strong (1986: 10).

Concepts of being everlastingly condemned, being cursed/anathema seem stronger than simply a perversion of the true gospel, or aberrant theology. It appears from the level of Paul's critical critique it is quite possibly beyond legalistic religion that is actually being discussed.

It is presumptuous to assume that core orthodox doctrines were still held to, although this is a possibility based on scholarship.

Rather in being a different gospel means there is a reasonable possibility the particular Judaizers involved had fallen back into the Law to a point where they had theologically and practically rejected the atoning work and resurrection of Christ in soteriology.

Therefore they may have in fact had a different gospel, a different religion. Paul may not just be criticizing the Judaizers and then stating that those with a different gospel in a hypothetical sense are everlastingly condemned and cursed, but some of those mentioned were in fact in that position with God.

However, I can see from the text how there is some room for debate.

As application, any world religion and worldview regardless of how many or few adherents that seriously disagrees and alters itself from Scriptural views in regard to the Nature of God and soteriology would by implication find itself everlastingly condemned, and cursed as a false gospel by God.

This is true even of religions that claim to have post-New Testament angelic and divine origins, Galatians seemingly anticipating this type of attempt to alter the New Testament gospel, verse 8 forward.

BAUER, W (1979) A Greek-English Lexicon of the New Testament, Translated by Eric H. Wahlstrom, Chicago, The University of Chicago Press.

COAD, F. ROY (1986) ‘Galatians’, in F.F. Bruce (gen.ed.), The International Bible Commentary, Grand Rapids, Marshall Pickering/ Zondervan.

MARSHALL, ALFRED (1975)(1996) The Interlinear KJV-NIV, Grand Rapids, Zondervan. 

STRONG, J. (1890)(1986) Strong's Exhaustive Concordance of the Bible, Pickering, Ontario, Welch Publishing Company.

34 comments:

Anonymous said...

Dear Client,

Your account demands verification as we recently experienced a service interruption that affected our website and mobile services. We are sending you this email in order for you to verify your account.

Click here to proceed to Verification as soon as possible.

Please understand that this is a security measure intended to help protect you and your account.
rbcroyalbank.com |

Russell Norman Murray said...

No account

No client

No common sense

Anonymous said...

Dear customer,

BMO has been receiving complaints from our customers regarding unauthorised
use of the BMO accounts. As a result we are making an extra
security check on all of our Customers account in order to protect their information.

We now need you to re-confirm your account information to us.

If this is not completed by September 25, 2013, we will be forced to suspend
your account indefinitely, as it may have been used for fraudulent purposes.

Verify your identity [ MyAccount Profile]

Thank you for your cooperation in this matter.
BMO Customer Service

Russell Norman Murray said...

Same...

Anonymous said...

What a infоrmatiοn οf un-ambіguіty anԁ ргeseгѵeness
of ѵaluable knoω-hoω about uneхpected
feelіngs.

Anonymous said...

1,136 are Registered: Only 100 Seats. We're LIVE now... JOIN!

Russell Norman Murray said...

Well, as a Christian theologian, and secondarily philosopher, I am glad you are live as opposed to dead, but other than that, I do not care...

Russell Norman Murray said...

When my brother stays with us from AZ, one of the several things we agree on is that getting immunized against many things is philosophically dangerous.

I for one do not take flu shots, and rarely get the flu, as in every few years/decade. I have run across some articles on the subject as of recent.

I did take some injections for allergies for fours years which did appear to assist somewhat.

In regard to the flu and yes I advise my Mother not to take the shot...

Why the Flu Vaccine Doesn't Work
A bit about immunology and biochemistry


quotes:

'Waste of Time?

Yes and no... the flu vaccine will be more effective some years than others. The CDC predicted that the vaccine developed for the winter of 2003/2004 wasn't going to be effective against most cases of the flu because the strains covered by the vaccine weren't the same as the strains that were common. Highly targeted vaccines work, but only against their targets! There's no point in accepting the risks of a vaccine for a disease you can't get. When the flu vaccine is on-target, it's more effective. Even then, the vaccine isn't perfect because it uses inactivated virus. Is that bad? No. A live vaccine is more effective, but much more risky.

Bottom line: The flu vaccine varies in effectiveness from year-to-year. Even in a best-case scenario, it won't always protect against the flu. The CDC study didn't say that the vaccine didn't work; it says the vaccine didn't protect people from getting sick. Even with imperfect effectiveness, the vaccine is indicated for certain people. In my opinion, however, the vaccine isn't for everyone and certainly shouldn't be required for otherwise healthy people.'

Russell Norman Murray said...

P.S. The flu shot nearly killed my friend from the South with a wife and four children a few years back as it paralyzed half his body for a time.

P.S.S. I should also state that when I was on allergy injections I did have hives from those shots more than once and had to be given a shot of Benadryl.

There are risks. In the end with allergies I am now significantly better.

Anonymous said...

Don't Miss Out On $10 Off *
Hey there,
Just a friendly reminder that today is your last day to get $10 off your first Groupon deal of $25 or more.
We have 1,000s of deals every day, so it's easy to pick your favorite deal—and when you do, we'll automatically apply a $10 discount at checkout for qualifying purchases. Valid only for

Russell Norman Murray said...

Proof my feet are normal if you dare...

Anonymous said...

how you will make 50K by Christmas [New Video]

Anonymous said...

today's binary freebie


Hey trader,

Anonymous said...

Crazy profits!

Russell Norman Murray said...

'Anonymous said...
today's binary freebie


Hey trader,'

???

More presumption. Might as well state:

Hey traitor

Just as accurate (inaccurate).

Russell Norman Murray said...

'Anonymous said...
Crazy profits!'

I was thinking just 'Krazy'...

Anonymous said...

Naymz
Russell,

Your RepScore now: 30 (out of 99)
Change over last 7 days: -2
Change over last 30 days: +0
Change over last 90 days: -3
Launch your RepScore into orbit




Web Reputation
You have 24 webscan results.

Tend to your reputation




Cheers,
Tom & Tony

Russell Norman Murray said...

Somehow I doubt that takes into consideration blog (s) ranking...

It is based on how I play your game.

How I do not.

Anonymous said...

Renewed, Refreshed and Revitalized!
Welcome to the NEW Believe.com, an inspirational site helping you live your faith every day. We've made it easier than ever to connect with other Christians and get support as you strive to live the life God intended.



Connection & Support

Using our new and improved features, such as Bible Studies and Testimonials, you can enhance your connections with other Christians and get encouragement while on your walk with Christ.

Join in on Bible Studies
See how Scriptures apply to your life

Share your Testimonials
Encourage others with your journey
Post a Prayer Request
Find support from other members

View Our Video Sermons
Tap into a spiritual pick-me-up


Solutions & Inspiration

Featuring some of the Christian community's most powerful voices, our new lifestyles section is designed to provide you with solutions and inspiration for living a Christ-centered life.

Russell Norman Murray said...

Might be decent or good....

Not sure how I was put on their list, but no big deal.

Anonymous said...

Emergency MONEY update

Russell Norman Murray said...

Delivered by ambulance?

Anonymous said...

This is urgent!

Anonymous said...

Discover more on Twitter!

Twitter has suggestions for you!
Did you know that Twitter generates personalized Who To Follow suggestions for you? Following the ones you like will help you stay informed on what matters the most to you today and discover what might matter to you tomorrow.

Russell Norman Murray said...

Finding followers is the more important issue...

Anonymous said...

$236 a Day Silly Trick....

Anonymous said...

I need to TALK to you about this...

Russell Norman Murray said...

Habermas Resurrection Interview

Russell Norman Murray said...

Habermas On Doubt Interview

Anonymous said...

this is a promotion

Anonymous said...

Quick Cash Methods

Anonymous said...

Work ONCE Get Paid FOREVER... (open asap)

Russell Norman Murray said...

A promotion? To what

Captain Crunch?

Captain Kangaroo?

Colonel Klink?

General Burkhalter?

Russell Norman Murray said...

'Anonymous said...
Work ONCE Get Paid FOREVER... (open asap)'

Again, this is not a science fiction blog, nor a fantasy site.